2425 Eglinton Ave. East #12, Scarborough

Colic and Constant Crying in Scarborough: Getting Through the Evening Storms

Hours of evening crying can shake even calm parents. This Scarborough guide covers colic, soothing ideas, coping when you're at your limit and signs of illness.

11 min read

Parent seen from behind holding a swaddled newborn by a lamp-lit window at snowy dusk

It often starts around the same time every evening. Dinner is half-cooked, the light outside is fading over the rooftops, and the baby who was content all afternoon suddenly begins to scream. Not fuss. Scream. Legs pulled up, fists clenched, face red, and nothing you try seems to make the slightest difference. You feed, you burp, you change the diaper, you walk the hallway, and an hour later you are still walking.

If that scene sounds familiar, you are in very large company. Prolonged, hard-to-settle crying in the early months is one of the most common reasons parents call a nurse line or bring a baby to a clinic, and in most cases the baby is healthy. That does not make it easy. Hours of crying wear on sleep, on relationships, on patience, and on the confidence of even the most experienced parent or grandparent.

This guide is for families in Scarborough living through that stage right now. It explains what doctors mean by colic, what normal infant crying looks like, which soothing ideas are worth trying, how to protect yourself and your baby when you hit your limit, and the signs that suggest crying is coming from illness rather than ordinary colic.

What normal crying looks like in the first months

Crying is a baby’s main way of communicating. In the first weeks it signals hunger, a wet diaper, being too hot or cold, wanting to be held, or simply being overwhelmed by a world full of light and noise. Even content, healthy babies cry a fair amount.

A few patterns are well recognised:

  • Crying tends to increase after the first couple of weeks, often peaking somewhere around six to eight weeks of age.
  • It usually eases by three to four months. Many parents notice a gradual shift rather than an overnight change.
  • Late afternoon and evening are common peak times. Nobody fully understands why, but the “witching hour” is real for many families.
  • Some crying happens for no reason you can find. A baby can be fed, clean, warm and held, and still cry.

Some child-development experts describe this whole normal phase using the word PURPLE, a teaching tool that reminds parents the crying peaks, can be unexpected, may resist soothing, can make a baby look as though they are in pain, can be long-lasting, and often happens in the evening. The point of that framing is reassuring: this is a stage, not a sign that you are doing something wrong.

So what is colic, exactly?

Colic is not a disease. It is a description. Doctors traditionally use it for a healthy, well-growing baby who cries for long stretches without an obvious cause. An older rule of thumb, sometimes called the “rule of threes”, describes crying for more than three hours a day, on more than three days a week, for more than three weeks. In everyday practice, clinicians use it more loosely: lots of inconsolable crying in an otherwise healthy young baby.

The causes are not well understood, and probably differ from one baby to the next. Theories include an immature nervous system that has trouble self-calming, sensitivity to stimulation, gas or a developing gut, and in a minority of babies, a reaction to cow’s milk protein. What colic is not is a reflection of poor parenting, a “spoiled” baby, or a sign that your milk is somehow inadequate.

Why seeing a doctor still matters

Because colic is a label for crying without another explanation, the first step is making sure there is no other explanation. A clinician will ask about feeding, stools, vomiting, weight gain and sleep, and will examine your baby from head to toe. Weight gain is especially reassuring. A baby who is feeding well and growing along their curve is far less likely to have something serious going on. If your baby is due for a check, well-baby visits are a natural time to raise crying concerns, and you do not need to wait for one if you are worried.

Soothing strategies worth trying

No single technique works for every baby, and something that worked last Tuesday may fail tonight. It helps to think of soothing as a toolbox rather than a fix. Try one approach calmly for a few minutes before switching, since rapid changes can overstimulate a baby who is already overwhelmed.

Motion and closeness

  • Hold your baby close, skin to skin or against your chest, and sway or rock gently.
  • Walk slowly around the room or down the hallway. Many babies settle with the rhythm of steady footsteps.
  • Try a baby carrier so you can keep your hands free while baby stays close.
  • A drive or stroller walk sometimes helps, but on icy March sidewalks or after a sleepless night, only go out if you are alert and safe to do so.

Sound and environment

  • Steady “shushing” close to the ear, or white noise from a fan or app, mimics the constant sound babies heard before birth. Keep the volume moderate and the device away from the crib.
  • Dim the lights and reduce visitors, screens and household chatter. An overtired baby in a busy room may need less, not more.
  • Check the temperature. Bundling babies heavily against the cold is common in a Scarborough winter, but overheating can make a baby fussy, and it matters for sleep safety too.
  • Pause for burping during and after feeds.
  • If bottle-feeding, ask about paced feeding and check that the nipple flow is not too fast.
  • Offer a pacifier if your baby takes one, once breastfeeding is well established.
  • If you are breastfeeding, do not cut out foods on your own. In some babies with suspected cow’s milk protein sensitivity, a doctor may suggest a time-limited trial of removing dairy from the parent’s diet, but that is a decision to make together, so your own nutrition is protected.
  • Avoid switching formulas repeatedly without advice. Frequent changes can confuse the picture and rarely solve the problem.

What about drops and remedies?

Parents are often offered gas drops, gripe water, herbal teas or special supplements by well-meaning relatives or online stores. Evidence for most of them is weak or mixed, and some herbal products are not regulated in the same way as medicines. Some probiotics have been studied for colic in breastfed babies with mixed results. Never give honey to a baby under one year, and check with a doctor or pharmacist before giving any product, especially to a young infant.

Make a calm-down plan before the crying starts

Many families find it helps to agree on a plan in daylight, before the evening storm. Who takes the first shift? What will you try first? When will you hand over? Writing it on the fridge sounds simple, but at 9 p.m. with a screaming baby, a simple plan beats improvisation.

When you reach your limit: a word about shaking

This section matters as much as anything else in this article.

Inconsolable crying is the most common trigger for a baby being shaken. Shaking a baby, even briefly, can cause bleeding in the brain, permanent brain injury, blindness or death. A baby’s neck is weak and their head is heavy relative to their body, so the brain moves violently inside the skull. It can happen in a few seconds of frustration, by people who love the baby deeply.

Feeling angry, resentful, or desperate during a long crying spell does not make you a bad parent. Those feelings are a normal response to an abnormal amount of stress. What matters is what you do with them. If you feel your frustration rising:

  1. Put the baby down safely on their back in a crib or bassinet with nothing else in it.
  2. Walk away. Close the door, go to another room, and take ten minutes to breathe, drink some water, or step onto the balcony.
  3. Call someone. A partner, a friend, a family member, a neighbour. Ask them to come over or just to talk you down.
  4. Check on the baby every few minutes. Crying in a safe crib will not harm your baby.

Letting a healthy baby cry in a safe place while you calm down is always the right choice over continuing to hold them when you feel you might lose control. Share this message with everyone who cares for your baby, including grandparents, older siblings, babysitters and new partners. In Scarborough’s many multigenerational households, a grandparent may be doing the late-evening walking while parents work shifts, and they deserve the same information and the same permission to put the baby down.

Looking after the caregivers

Colic does not only affect babies. Weeks of evening crying are linked to exhaustion, strain between partners, and in some parents, postpartum depression or anxiety. Signs that a parent needs support include feeling hopeless, unable to enjoy anything, constantly on edge, unable to sleep even when the baby sleeps, or having thoughts of harming yourself or the baby.

A few practical ideas help many families:

  • Take shifts. One adult covers the evening while the other sleeps with earplugs, then swap.
  • Accept help with specifics. “Can you hold her from seven to nine on Thursday?” works better than “Let me know if you need anything.”
  • Lower the bar. Takeout, paper plates and laundry piles are fine for now.
  • Get outside in daylight. Even a short walk around the block on a mild late-winter afternoon can reset a frazzled nervous system.
  • Talk to a doctor about yourself, too. Your mental health is a medical issue, not an indulgence.

Many newcomer families in Scarborough are raising their first baby far from the aunts, mothers and neighbours who would traditionally share the load. If that is your situation, it is worth being honest with your doctor about how isolated you feel. Health811 (call 811) also offers free, 24-hour advice from registered nurses in Ontario, which can be reassuring in the middle of the night.

If you ever feel you might hurt yourself or your baby, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department right away.

When crying is a sign of illness

Colic is a diagnosis made only after other causes are considered. Certain features suggest something else may be going on and deserve prompt medical attention.

Call 911 or go to the emergency department if your baby:

  • Is under three months old and has a rectal temperature of 38.0°C or higher
  • Has trouble breathing, is grunting, or their lips or face look blue or grey
  • Is very difficult to wake, floppy, or unusually limp
  • Has a seizure
  • Vomits green or yellow-green fluid, or vomits forcefully after every feed
  • Has a swollen, tense or bulging soft spot on the head
  • May have been shaken, dropped, or injured in any way

Book a prompt visit if you notice:

  • Crying that sounds very different from usual, such as high-pitched or weak and moaning
  • Poor feeding, refusing feeds, or fewer wet diapers than normal
  • Blood in the stool or very persistent diarrhea
  • Frequent vomiting, or back-arching and distress during most feeds
  • Poor weight gain or weight loss
  • A rash, fever in an older baby, or any illness alongside the crying
  • Crying that starts suddenly in a baby who was previously calm, or that continues beyond about four months

Our fever assessment page explains how we evaluate a feverish child, but remember that any fever in a baby under three months old needs emergency-level care, not a walk-in visit.

Common treatable causes doctors check for

When a baby’s crying has a cause, it is often something a clinician can find and address. Examples include an ear infection, a urinary infection, reflux causing real discomfort, constipation, a hair wrapped tightly around a finger or toe, a scratch on the eye, a hernia, or a feeding problem such as a poor latch. This is why a hands-on examination is valuable, even when you suspect “it’s just colic.”

What to bring to the appointment

A little preparation helps your visit go further. If you can, note down:

  • When the crying happens and roughly how long it lasts
  • How and how often your baby feeds, and how much if bottle-fed
  • Number of wet and dirty diapers per day, and what the stools look like
  • Any vomiting, fever, rash or breathing changes
  • Anything that seems to help or make things worse
  • Any products, drops or remedies you have already tried
  • How you and your partner or family are coping

A short phone video of a typical crying episode can also be surprisingly helpful, since babies have a way of being perfectly calm the moment they arrive in the exam room.

The light at the end of the tunnel

It can be hard to believe in the middle of week six, but colic does end. For most babies, the long evening crying fades by three to four months, often around the time they start to smile more, discover their hands, and take an interest in the world around them. Babies who had colic generally grow into healthy, happy children, and there is no evidence that responding warmly to a crying infant “spoils” them.

Until then, the goal is not to stop every tear. It is to keep your baby safe, rule out illness, find a few tools that sometimes help, and keep the adults in the house rested and supported enough to get through it.

Support for crying babies and tired families in Scarborough

If your baby’s crying has you worried, or you simply need someone to examine your little one and tell you whether things look healthy, HealthSmart Medical is here to help. Our team offers paediatric care and same-day appointments for babies and children, along with support for parents who are running on empty.

We are located at 2425 Eglinton Ave. East, Unit 12, in Scarborough, a short trip for families along the Eglinton corridor. Call us at 416-757-7117 or book online. Bring the crying diary, bring the questions, and bring a support person if you can. You do not have to get through this stage alone.

This article is for general information and is not a substitute for medical advice. If you have severe or worsening symptoms, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Visit HealthSmart Medical

Care close to home in Scarborough.

Find us at 2425 Eglinton Ave. East #12, Scarborough, Ontario M1K 5G8. Walk-in appointments are available Monday to Saturday, and our family doctor registration is open for new patients.