2425 Eglinton Ave. East #12, Scarborough

Advance Care Planning in Scarborough: Choosing Who Speaks for You and Sharing What Matters

Substitute decision-makers, power of attorney for personal care, and family conversations across cultures, explained for Scarborough adults planning ahead.

10 min read

Older woman and her adult daughter holding hands across a kitchen table with tea and papers

Most families have the conversation at the worst possible time. A parent has a stroke, or a grandfather is admitted to hospital with pneumonia and becomes too confused to answer questions. A doctor in the hallway asks, “Who makes decisions for him?” and three siblings look at each other. One says he would want everything done. Another remembers him saying he never wanted to be kept alive on machines. Nobody is sure, and everyone is frightened.

Advance care planning is about making that moment easier. It means thinking ahead about who you would want to speak for you if you could not speak for yourself, and talking with them now about what matters to you. It is not only for people who are elderly or seriously ill. An accident or sudden illness can happen at any age, and the people who love you will be better able to help if they know what you value.

This article explains how advance care planning works in Ontario in general terms, what a substitute decision-maker is, how a power of attorney for personal care fits in, and how to start the conversation in families where these topics can feel difficult. It is written for adults in Scarborough of any age, and for the adult children who may one day be asked to make decisions for a parent.

What advance care planning is, and what it is not

Advance care planning has two main parts:

  1. Knowing who your substitute decision-maker (SDM) would be, and confirming or choosing that person.
  2. Sharing your wishes, values, and beliefs with that person and others close to you, so they understand what kind of care you would want.

It is worth being clear about a few things it is not.

  • It is not a one-time form. It is a series of conversations that can change as your health and life change.
  • It is not the same as consenting to treatment in advance. In Ontario, health care providers ask for consent at the time a decision needs to be made. If you are capable, they ask you. If you are not, they ask your SDM, who uses what they know about your wishes and values to decide.
  • It is not only about the end of life. Plans can matter during a temporary illness, a period of confusion after surgery, or a long hospital stay from which you are expected to recover.
  • It is not giving up. Many people who plan ahead go on to receive active treatment for years. Planning simply makes sure the care fits the person.

Because laws and forms have specific requirements, the details in this article are general. For legal documents, speak with a lawyer or consult the official Ontario government resources.

Substitute decision-makers in Ontario

A substitute decision-maker is the person who makes health care decisions on your behalf if you become mentally incapable of making a particular decision yourself. Capacity is decision-specific. A person may be able to decide what to eat for lunch but not be able to weigh the risks and benefits of a major surgery, and capacity can come and go during an illness.

If you do nothing, Ontario law still names someone

Ontario has a ranked list that determines who your SDM would be if you have not formally appointed anyone. In broad terms, it starts with any court-appointed guardian or person you named in a power of attorney for personal care, then moves to a spouse or partner, then children or parents, then brothers and sisters, then other relatives. If there is no one available or willing, a provincial office called the Public Guardian and Trustee can act as a decision-maker of last resort.

The person must be willing, available, and capable of making the decision, and generally must be at least 16 years old. When several people share the same rank, such as three adult children, they are expected to agree. If they cannot, the situation can become stressful and, in some cases, may need outside help to resolve.

Is the automatic person the right person?

For many people, the person the law would choose is exactly who they would pick. For others, it is not. Consider:

  • If your relationships are complicated, such as a recent separation, a blended family, or estrangement from a relative, it may not be obvious who ranks first.
  • A large family with several adult children may struggle to reach a joint decision under pressure.
  • The person who ranks highest may live overseas, be unwell themselves, or simply be uncomfortable with the role.
  • You may feel a particular friend or relative understands your values better than anyone.

If the automatic choice does not suit you, that is when a power of attorney for personal care becomes important.

Power of attorney for personal care, in plain terms

A power of attorney for personal care is a legal document in which you name one or more people to make personal care decisions, including health care, if you become incapable. The person you name is called your attorney, though they do not need to be a lawyer.

A few general points:

  • It is separate from a power of attorney for property, which covers finances. Many people make both at the same time, but they are different documents and can name different people.
  • The Ontario government provides a free kit with forms and instructions. You can also have a lawyer prepare one, which may be helpful if your situation is complicated.
  • There are rules about who can witness the document. A lawyer or the government kit can explain them.
  • You can include instructions or wishes in the document, but the most useful thing is usually to talk with your attorney directly so they understand the reasoning behind your wishes.
  • You can change or cancel it while you are still capable.

Your family doctor does not prepare legal documents, but can talk with you about how your health might shape the decisions your attorney may face.

What to talk about with your decision-maker

Naming someone is only half the job. The other half is helping them understand you. Specific medical scenarios are hard to predict, so it often works better to talk about values. Some questions to think through:

  • What makes a day worth living for you? Being able to recognize family? Being at home? Eating your favourite foods? Praying or attending services?
  • Are there situations you would find unacceptable, such as being permanently unable to communicate?
  • How do you feel about treatments like life support, a breathing machine, or feeding tubes in different circumstances?
  • If you were very ill, would you prefer to be at home, in hospital, or somewhere else if possible?
  • Are there religious or cultural practices that matter to you around illness and death?
  • Who else should be involved in discussions, even if they are not the decision-maker?
  • What worries you most about becoming seriously ill?

You do not need to have firm answers to all of these. Saying “I’m not sure, but here is what matters most to me” gives your decision-maker a great deal to work with.

Writing it down

Some people find it useful to write a short letter to their SDM or keep notes with their important papers. Tell people where those papers are. A document locked in a drawer that no one knows about cannot help anyone.

Talking with family across cultures and generations

Scarborough is home to families from nearly every part of the world, often with several generations under one roof. That richness also means families bring very different expectations to these conversations.

When talking about death feels taboo

In some cultures, speaking openly about serious illness or death is believed to bring bad luck, or is considered disrespectful to elders. Some families prefer that difficult news be shared first with the eldest son or with the family as a group, rather than with the patient. Others see decisions as belonging to the whole family rather than to one individual.

These preferences deserve respect. Advance care planning does not have to mean a blunt conversation about dying. It can start in gentler ways:

  • Talk about values, not machines. “What has made your life meaningful?” or “What would you want us to remember if you were very sick?”
  • Use a story. A relative’s or neighbour’s illness, a news item, or a hospital visit can open the door naturally.
  • Frame it as care for the family. Many parents who will not discuss their own wishes will agree to it when they understand it would spare their children painful guessing later.
  • Involve a trusted person. A faith leader, an elder, or a respected family friend can sometimes guide the conversation more comfortably than a son or daughter.
  • Allow several conversations. It is fine to raise the topic, step back, and return to it weeks later.

Language matters

If a parent is more comfortable in Tamil, Tagalog, Urdu, Cantonese, Gujarati, or another language, have the conversation in that language. In a medical setting, ask about interpreter services. It may feel natural for a bilingual grandchild to translate, but these discussions involve sensitive and technical ideas, and it is a heavy burden to place on a young person.

When family members disagree

Disagreements are common, especially among siblings. Try to keep the focus on what your parent would want, not what each of you would want for yourselves. If the conversation becomes stuck, a family meeting with your parent’s doctor can help everyone hear the same medical information at the same time.

How your family doctor can help

Your family doctor knows your health history and is well placed to support advance care planning. During a regular visit, or one booked specifically for this purpose, your doctor can:

  • Explain your current health conditions and what they may mean for the future, in plain language
  • Talk through the kinds of decisions people with similar conditions sometimes face
  • Answer questions about treatments such as CPR, life support, or hospital admission in general terms
  • Help you think about your values and how they relate to your care
  • Note who your SDM is in your medical record, so it can be found if needed
  • Revisit the conversation as your health changes

Advance care planning is especially worth raising if you live with a long-term condition such as heart failure, COPD, kidney disease, or memory problems, or if you are an older adult. If you are managing several conditions, regular chronic disease follow-up care is a natural time to bring it up. An annual physical exam is another good opportunity.

It helps to bring your SDM to the appointment if you can. Hearing the same information together reduces confusion later.

Practical steps to take this month

If this all feels like a lot, start small. Here is a simple checklist:

  • Identify your SDM. Look at who Ontario’s list would name for you and decide if that suits you.
  • Consider a power of attorney for personal care if you want someone different, or if you want to be certain.
  • Have one conversation. Tell your decision-maker one or two things that matter most to you.
  • Tell your doctor who your SDM is.
  • Store your papers safely and tell people where they are.
  • Review your plan after a major life event, such as a new diagnosis, a marriage or separation, the death of someone close, or a move.

As the weather turns colder and families start gathering for the holidays and winter celebrations, many people find it a natural time to open these conversations.

When decisions are needed urgently

If someone has a sudden medical emergency, such as chest pain, difficulty breathing, signs of stroke, or collapse, call 911 right away. Do not delay emergency care because a plan has not been completed. Hospital teams will look for the right SDM and work with your family.

If you have questions about a family member’s current care in hospital, ask to speak with the most responsible physician or the care team. They can explain what decisions are being considered and who is being asked to make them.

Planning ahead with a family doctor in Scarborough

Advance care planning is one of the kindest things you can do for the people you love. It gives them a clearer picture of who you are and what you would want, so that if they are ever asked to decide for you, they can do so with confidence rather than guilt.

If you would like to talk through your health and your wishes, our family doctor team at HealthSmart Medical in Scarborough is glad to help, and you are welcome to bring your decision-maker along. You can book online or call 416-757-7117. We are at 2425 Eglinton Ave. East, Unit 12, in Scarborough.

This article is for general information and is not a substitute for medical advice. If you have severe or worsening symptoms, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Visit HealthSmart Medical

Care close to home in Scarborough.

Find us at 2425 Eglinton Ave. East #12, Scarborough, Ontario M1K 5G8. Walk-in appointments are available Monday to Saturday, and our family doctor registration is open for new patients.